Portfolio Challenge: Round 3

laksharemk wrote:

laksharemk wrote:My pics

DIMO 400,000
LOFC 200,000
FLCH 200,000
CIC.X 200,000

Mine still not updated in excel sheet.
Something wrong

Dear Moderators,

My pics still not updated in excel sheet, can you please check and update.

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

someone sell HARI pls

hurrayy...go HARI go

gran 500000
bfl 250000
brown.n 250000

Any update in this game?

Who is the winner

Who's the winner of Round 2 ?

I would appreciate if all participants could calculate their own portfolio value and post it in this thread so that we could determine the winner. Moderators will verify their calculation.

My closing portfolio value : Rs 930,841 (Declined by 6.9%)

no need to calculate,im in loss..

We will have a interesting situation. If by chance everybody is at a loss , are we going to give the award to smallest looser?

I did not participate on principal, but maybe I will in the future.

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

I know this is your virtual investment. I ask another question. Did'nt you by HARI shares actually.

Rajaraam wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

I know this is your virtual investment. I ask another question. Did'nt you by HARI shares actually.

nop

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

Market sucker:

You need to calculate loss on EAST on below.


EAST closing price on Sept 15th is Rs 35.7
Nov 30th price is 28.0

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded
2011-09-15 39.6 39.6 35.7 36.0 485600


On HARI you were smart. ( to pick a share which dropped Rs 1300 only on 100 shares traded).



With no offence to Market Sucker (as you played within the current rules, except for EAST calculation)


but as a Note to Admin for the need for future guideline revisions for the competition
just take the HARI example itself as an issue


No shares were traded for a month before sept 15th. Only 100 shares were traded at Rs 1600 on august 19th. Even if one want to
they could not have bought Rs700K worth of shares.

This issue was discussed before. In future it is best to atleast note that we need to pick a share that traded within say mayeb a week before the closing date with quantity atleast matching the players ( this game) quantity requested.

Again MarketSucker do not take it personal as you played within the current rule.

Am just pointing out this loophole to admin.




HARI :

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded

2011-10-07 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-10-03 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 300
2011-09-26 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-08-19 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 100
2011-08-12 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-08-04 2600.0 2900.0 2600.0 2900.0 300
2011-08-03 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-07-28 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 100

slstock wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

Market sucker:

You need to calculate loss on EAST on below.


EAST closing price on Sept 15th is Rs 35.7
Nov 30th price is 28.0

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded
2011-09-15 39.6 39.6 35.7 36.0 485600


On HARI you were smart. ( to pick a share which dropped Rs 1300 only on 100 shares traded).



With no offence to Market Sucker (as you played within the current rules, except for EAST calculation)


but as a Note to Admin for the need for future guideline revisions for the competition
just take the HARI example itself as an issue


No shares were traded for a month before sept 15th. Only 100 shares were traded at Rs 1600 on august 19th. Even if one want to
they could not have bought Rs700K worth of shares.

This issue was discussed before. In future it is best to atleast note that we need to pick a share that traded within say mayeb a week before the closing date with quantity atleast matching the players ( this game) quantity requested.

Again MarketSucker do not take it personal as you played within the current rule.

Am just pointing out this loophole to admin.




HARI :

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded

2011-10-07 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-10-03 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 300
2011-09-26 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-08-19 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 100
2011-08-12 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-08-04 2600.0 2900.0 2600.0 2900.0 300
2011-08-03 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-07-28 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 100

SORRY,thanks for counting real value

Market Sucker wrote:

slstock wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

Market sucker:

You need to calculate loss on EAST on below.


EAST closing price on Sept 15th is Rs 35.7
Nov 30th price is 28.0

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded
2011-09-15 39.6 39.6 35.7 36.0 485600


On HARI you were smart. ( to pick a share which dropped Rs 1300 only on 100 shares traded).



With no offence to Market Sucker (as you played within the current rules, except for EAST calculation)


but as a Note to Admin for the need for future guideline revisions for the competition
just take the HARI example itself as an issue


No shares were traded for a month before sept 15th. Only 100 shares were traded at Rs 1600 on august 19th. Even if one want to
they could not have bought Rs700K worth of shares.

This issue was discussed before. In future it is best to atleast note that we need to pick a share that traded within say mayeb a week before the closing date with quantity atleast matching the players ( this game) quantity requested.

Again MarketSucker do not take it personal as you played within the current rule.

Am just pointing out this loophole to admin.




HARI :

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded

2011-10-07 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-10-03 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 300
2011-09-26 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-08-19 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 100
2011-08-12 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-08-04 2600.0 2900.0 2600.0 2900.0 300
2011-08-03 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-07-28 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 100

SORRY,thanks for counting real value

Actually closing price of Sept 14th needs to be taken in account.

EAST closing price sept 14th was Rs 36.1. Don;t think it will make a massive differecence.

slstock wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:

Market Sucker wrote:HARI-700K
EAST-300K

HARI was 1600 at closing day
EAST was around 30-33 as i rmmbr


END PRICES-HARI-2900
EAST-around 28

ok will get HARI;s contribution(700K/1600*2900)=1,268,750
EAST(300000/33*28)=254,545

81% return from HARI...........


END Value=1,523,295Rs


is there any players got more then me?

Market sucker:

You need to calculate loss on EAST on below.


EAST closing price on Sept 15th is Rs 35.7
Nov 30th price is 28.0

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded
2011-09-15 39.6 39.6 35.7 36.0 485600


On HARI you were smart. ( to pick a share which dropped Rs 1300 only on 100 shares traded).



With no offence to Market Sucker (as you played within the current rules, except for EAST calculation)


but as a Note to Admin for the need for future guideline revisions for the competition
just take the HARI example itself as an issue


No shares were traded for a month before sept 15th. Only 100 shares were traded at Rs 1600 on august 19th. Even if one want to
they could not have bought Rs700K worth of shares.

This issue was discussed before. In future it is best to atleast note that we need to pick a share that traded within say mayeb a week before the closing date with quantity atleast matching the players ( this game) quantity requested.

Again MarketSucker do not take it personal as you played within the current rule.

Am just pointing out this loophole to admin.




HARI :

Date Open Hi Low Close Share traded

2011-10-07 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-10-03 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 2950.0 300
2011-09-26 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-08-19 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 1600.0 100
2011-08-12 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 2900.0 100
2011-08-04 2600.0 2900.0 2600.0 2900.0 300
2011-08-03 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 2400.0 100
2011-07-28 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 1900.0 100

fully agree,there should be some restriction in here after,btw he seems a player as to current rules.

I am awaiting until everybody submit their portfolio valuations to declare the winner of the 3rd Round and request the donor to make available the voluntry price money directly to the winner. Closing date for final submission of portfolio valuations would be 31st December 2011. All players are requested to submit their valuations have to be submitted in this thread. Any valuation submitted after this day would not be accepted or considered.

We hope to launch a fully comprehensive stock market stimulation game in January 2012.

Quibit wrote:I am awaiting until everybody submit their portfolio valuations to declare the winner of the 3rd Round and request the donor to make available the voluntry price money directly to the winner. Closing date for final submission of portfolio valuations would be 31st December 2011. All players are requested to submit their valuations have to be submitted in this thread. Any valuation submitted after this day would not be accepted or considered.

We hope to launch a fully comprehensive stock market stimulation game in January 2012.

Official Result Out?

Kumar wrote:

Quibit wrote:I am awaiting until everybody submit their portfolio valuations to declare the winner of the 3rd Round and request the donor to make available the voluntry price money directly to the winner. Closing date for final submission of portfolio valuations would be 31st December 2011. All players are requested to submit their valuations have to be submitted in this thread. Any valuation submitted after this day would not be accepted or considered.

We hope to launch a fully comprehensive stock market stimulation game in January 2012.

Official Result Out?

who is the winner we all had loss ne

Winner?

Kumar wrote:Winner?

Market Sucker. Congrads
100 shares of HARI made the difference.
QB postponed the end date to 31st Nov. Otherwise we could have few more gainers.
However under the current rules Market Sucker is the winner.

UKboy wrote:

Kumar wrote:Winner?

Market Sucker. Congrads
100 shares of HARI made the difference.
QB postponed the end date to 31st Nov. Otherwise we could have few more gainers.
However under the current rules Market Sucker is the winner.

Thanks UK Boy.
Just for a curiosity,that's all.
Congrats market sucker. Well done.

Kumar wrote:

UKboy wrote:

Kumar wrote:Winner?

Market Sucker. Congrads
100 shares of HARI made the difference.
QB postponed the end date to 31st Nov. Otherwise we could have few more gainers.
However under the current rules Market Sucker is the winner.

Thanks UK Boy.
Just for a curiosity,that's all.
Congrats market sucker. Well done.

thanks,but admin seems not going to verify this

Please let me know the winner and the details so that the promised money can be deposited in the winner's account

Moderators please go ahead and declare the winner. All those members who agreed to pay price money please go ahead and pay to the declared winner. Objective of the game was not achieved due to the illiquid nature of some stocks which allowed certain players to achieve better results losing spirit of the stock trading game. New game would be launched soon!!

Quibit wrote:Moderators please go ahead and declare the winner. All those members who agreed to pay price money please go ahead and pay to the declared winner. Objective of the game was not achieved due to the illiquid nature of some stocks which allowed certain players to achieve better results losing spirit of the stock trading game. New game would be launched soon!!

so quibi,cant we choose illiquids in next game?

HVA - 250,000 ( @ 26.7 )
EAST - 200,000 ( @ 17.6 )
GREG - 400,000 ( @ 25.6 )
PEG - 150,000 ( @ 58 )

Happy Pancha wrote:HVA - 250,000 ( @ 26.7 )
EAST - 200,000 ( @ 17.6 )
GREG - 400,000 ( @ 25.6 )
PEG - 150,000 ( @ 58 )

game started?

Quibit wrote:New game would be launched soon!!

any info?